Why the Healthy Workplace Bill is a not a “job killer”

In a New York Daily News op-ed piece last week, E.J. McMahon and James Copland of the Manhattan Institute attacked the Healthy Workplace Bill (HWB) as a “job killer” that would end at-will employment — i.e., the right of employers to terminate workers for any reason or no reason at all — in New York State.  They claimed that protecting people against abusive treatment at work would place an unfair burden on employers.

A New Jersey state of mind?

The “job killer” tag is a favorite of those who oppose laws to protect workers, suggesting that safeguards against mistreatment and harm translate into costs that “kill” jobs and chase them across state lines.  In the case of New York, opponents of the HWB are trying to scare people into believing that enactment of the bill will cause a rush of companies to pick up and move to New Jersey — a state that has some of the toughest worker protections in the nation!

Fair and balanced

Even apart from the reality that New Jersey is hardly an employer’s legal paradise, there are many reasons why the HWB is not the “job killer” Mssrs. McMahon and Copland claim it to be:

1.  High standard for proving a case — The HWB requires an individual to prove that the bullying behavior was malicious and harmful to physical and/or mental health.  By legal standards, that’s a high threshold.

2.  Damage cap for lesser claims — In cases where the bullying did not include a negative employment decision such as a demotion or termination, emotional distress damages are limited to $25,000 and no punitive damages are allowed.  In other words, the HWB blocks runaway jury verdicts for comparatively modest claims.

3.  Preserves management prerogatives — The HWB expressly maintains traditional management prerogatives to evaluate employees.  It does not do away with the rule of at-will employment.

4.  Incentives — The HWB imposes liability on employers, but it provides them with incentives to reduce or avoid liability by taking adequate preventive and responsive measures toward bullying.

5.  Notice — The New York version of the HWB requires employees to put employers on notice of bullying behavior as a pre-condition for filing a lawsuit.

An equal opportunity people saver, not a job killer

Most targets of severe workplace bullying fall between the cracks of existing labor protections.  The HWB is designed to fill this huge gap in the law.  It provides bullied workers who can prove that they were subjected to malicious, health-harming abuse with damages and relief.  These protections are truly “equal opportunity,” as they extend to everyone, regardless of their demographic characteristics.

The Healthy Workplace Bill promotes human dignity and productive organizations by recognizing that we all work better when we are not subjected to disabling, destructive abuse at work.  It’s not a job killer, it’s a people saver.


Earlier post on the Healthy Workplace Bill in New York

10 responses

  1. Pingback: NY Senate Healthy Workplace Bill press coverage

    • Seems the bill only requires that management become minimally civilized. If that causes certain businesses to fail, that’s good. In a real capitalist economic system, another business will be born to provide the same service/product but with more competent leadership. I’m all for that.

      • Larry, that’s it! The bill sets a high legal threshold for recovery of damages. It’s not a “slam dunk” for the employee/target by any stretch. If a business loses repeated cases under this statute to the point where its financial viability is threatened, maybe it should stand aside for a better competitor or replacement. David

  2. Outstanding explanation of the bill! I’m going to share this link on my blog so that others know what HWB is all about!

    Great job, David!

  3. Pingback: Why the Healthy Workplace Bill is not a “Job Killer” « Stop Workplace Bullies…Now!

  4. Pingback: NY Daily News: NY's latest "job killer"

  5. Pingback: New York workplace bullying legislation is in the news « Minding the Workplace

  6. Pingback: Workplace bullying laws only a matter of time, employers’ lawyers concede « Minding the Workplace

  7. Pingback: Opposing workplace bullying legislation: Are depression, PTSD, and suicide an “Emily Post problem”? « Minding the Workplace

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: