The moral obscenity of a “jobless recovery”

We should be alarmed by the growing and blithe use of the term “jobless recovery.”  Indeed, let’s look right under the surface to see what it means:

1. Recovery of profits and stock values that disproportionately benefit the people who have suffered least or not at all during the Great Recession.

2. Return of larger salaries and bonuses for top executives.

3. A “new normal” of high jobless rates, with more despair and desperation as people use up their unemployment benefits, drain their meager savings and retirement accounts, max out their credit cards, and lose their homes.

4. Further destruction of the middle class, with a widening gap between the richest and the poorest.

Suffering, not recovery

A “jobless recovery” is about human suffering, not a healthy economy. Most who invoke this term with a straight face presumably do not imagine themselves joining the millions of unemployed.  Rather, they see their jobs remaining relatively stable and their retirement accounts bouncing back from the worst of the meltdown. Too many have shelved any sense of empathy or urgency about an economy that is inflicting devastating pain on millions.

But make no mistake about it: Most of the gainfully employed are one job loss away from that very despair and desperation.  And how easily we forget that in a society with a frayed safety net, the falls come fast and hard.


For the U.S., I favor three key responses:

1.  Hire people and pay them a decent wage — In some sectors, corporate profits have roared back with a vengeance, yet companies aren’t hiring, and others are holding down wages and benefits for the rank-and-file.  As a society, we must send a message to companies that creating good jobs at good pay is part of the privilege of doing business, especially when revenues are strong.  It’s not about “capitalism” vs. “socialism” or left vs. right; it’s about how we conduct ourselves in a civil society.

2.  Create a jobs program — Among other things, we need a public works program that puts people back on a payroll doing the vital work of rebuilding America’s infrastructure. We’ve got nearly 41 million people on food stamps, with unemployment levels remaining high and steady.  We have roads and bridges in this country that are badly in need of repair, with safety and quality of life at stake.  Let’s match the need for jobs with the need to rebuild our country.

3.  Build a strong safety net — This recession is not about workers suddenly becoming lazy and unwilling to work.  Countless folks are pounding the pavements and scouring the Internet in search of decent jobs.  In the meantime, let’s support them through continued unemployment benefits, transitional assistance to train for vocations, and whatever help they need to secure their health care coverage.

2 responses

  1. Hi David, I must say I agree with everything you said-but I feel it is lacking something vital: We need conscious people who are not acting angry. Any anger added to this situation will continue to keep ‘sides.’

    Once we think of ourselves as ‘light’ and shining dispels the dark (it could be actions/conversations etc) then we are unhooked and will speak to the higher intelligence in others.

    It’s the only ‘cure’ to change our minds. To work anew, with the essence of what is happening. Why is someone motivated to the greed and accumulation of money? Because they identify with it (fear at work). Once they change their mind that they are NOT their possessions-they can hear the moral arguments.

    BTW-the ‘jobless’ are learning the same lesson “I am not my job, possessions, material goods” too. From a painful perspective-but that voice is critical as well.


  2. Karen, thanks for your comment. While I agree that we don’t want everyone acting angry, I definitely think the “sides” you refer to have been maintained by certain haves at the expense of the have-nots or the have-much-less. True, we are not our jobs and our possessions, but if we wait for the greedy and avaricious to see the light and gain that higher intelligence, people will literally starve to death in the meantime.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: